Cakes & Specialty Cakes

At Kathy’s Pies, we offer cakes for your special occasions.

Our flavors are white, chocolate and marble, with our made from scratch Butter cream frosting.
We can make your cake in a full sheet, half sheet, or 9”round and decorate them with your requested colors. (We currently do not offer any licensed characters.)
We request that you order your cake at least 2 days in advance.

Compare our full sheet prices to others when ordering for weddings – you will be pleasantly surprised to find us well below the competition.

Our chocolate and white cakes are available every day at our shop as slices with white frosting for $2.00 per slice. We also have them as cupcakes with seasonal decorations. A 4-pack is $2.80 and a 6-pack is $4.20, these are also available every day; order larger quantities and we will have them ready for you when you stop in.

4″ Cake

Perfect for baby’s first birthday! We make these in white or chocolate and can be decorated…we will need 2 days notice.

PRICE
$7.00

6″ Cake

This is the perfect size for 2 people. We make this in white or chocolate and have them available in house every day with white frosting on them. You may also order them with 2 days notice and have them decorated

PRICE
$11.50

9″ Round cake

Two layer cake that serves 16. Available in white, chocolate or marble. Basic decorating included, advanced extra

PRICE
$25.00

Amaretto Cheese Cake

This cheese cake has a crushed wafer and almond crust, very rich and creamy. Topped with candied almonds. Serves 16 – Limited Availability! Available by the slice in store for $2.95.

SLICE WHOLE CAKE
$2.95 $49.95

Baked Cheese Cake Slices

Stop by and grab a slice of Kathy’s famous cheesecake for only $2.95. Varieties include plain, lemon, chocolate, white chocolate raspberry, amaretto and pumpkin. Limited availably.

PRICE
$2.95

Carrot Cake

Made from scratch with sweet potatoes, apples, and of course, carrots! These two layer cakes are frosted with homemade cream cheese frosting and accented with cute little frosted carrots.

PRICE
$28.00

Chocolate Cheese Cake

This cheesecake is for serious chocolate lovers only! Best served with a red wine or cup of coffee. Slices available in store for $2.95.

SLICE WHOLE CAKE
$2.95 $39.95

Cup Cakes

White or Chocolate cupcakes topped with our buttercream frosting. These are available everyday

PRICE
$0.70

Full Sheet Cake

Available in white, chocolate, marble or half white/half chocolate. Serves 60-96. Add an edible image for $7.50 to $10.00. Basic decorating included, advanced extra.

PRICE
$50.00

German Chocolate Cup Cakes

Sweet coconut and pecans make this frosting arguably one of the best frostings on earth! And the lite chocolate cup cakes are good too!

PRICE
$1.95

Half Sheet

Available in white, chocolate or marble. Serves 30-48. Add an edible image for $5.00. Basic decorating included, advanced extra

PRICE
$35.00

Kathy’s Plain Baked Cheese Cake

Rich classic homemade cheese cake, made with cream cheese, sour cream and top shelf vanilla. Each cake is made by Kathy herself. We do have slices of this cheese cake available in our refrigerated case everyday. Whole frozen cakes available in limited quantities.

SLICE WHOLE CAKE
$2.95 $29.95

Pumpkin Cheese Cake

Fall classic, just like it sounds. Available with or without a cream cheese topping. Serves 16 – Limited Availability! Available by the slice in store $2.95.

SLICE WHOLE CAKE
$2.95 $34.95

Quarter Sheet Cake

Available in white, chocolate or marble. This size will serve 15-24. Add an edible image for $5.00. Basic decorating included, advanced extra.

PRICE
$22.00

Triple Chocolate Cupcakes

Just like the name says, this is a triple threat with chocolate chip cake, filled with dark chocolate frosting, topped with dark chocolate frosting. You need a whole gallon of milk with one of these!

PRICE
$2.29