Whole Pies

A variety of 10″ pies are available daily at the shop.

10″ pies will yield 8 servings each.

4″ Cake

Perfect for baby’s first birthday! We make these in white or chocolate and can be decorated…we will need 2 days notice.

PRICE
$7.00

6″ Cake

This is the perfect size for 2 people. We make this in white or chocolate and have them available in-house every day with white frosting on them. You may also order them with 2 days notice and have them decorated

PRICE
$12.95

9″ Round cake

Two layer cake that serves 16. Available in white, chocolate or marble. Basic decorating included, advanced extra

PRICE
$28.95

Amaretto Cheesecake

This cheesecake has a crushed wafer and almond crust, very rich and creamy. Topped with candied almonds. Serves 16 – Limited Availability! Available by the slice in store for $2.95.

SLICEWHOLE CAKE
$2.95$49.95

Order Online!

Apple

A great American standard, made with Granny Smith apples and a touch of cinnamon and nutmeg.

10″ PRICE8″ PRICE
$13.75$7.95

Order Online!

Baked Cheesecake Slices

Stop by and grab a slice of Kathy’s famous cheesecake for only $2.95. Varieties include plain, lemon, turtle pecan, white chocolate raspberry, amaretto and pumpkin. Limited availably.

PRICE
$2.95

Banana Cream

A single crust pie with real bananas in a banana flavored pudding, topped with either a meringue or a whipped topping – your preference must be indicated

10″ PRICE
$13.75

Order Online!

Banana Split Pie

This yummy creation is our pie of the month for August. (It is only available that month!) It has a banana…

10″ PRICE
$14.75

Carrot Cake

Made from scratch with sweet potatoes, apples, and of course, carrots! These cakes are frosted with homemade cream cheese frosting and accented with cute little frosting carrots. 6 inch round ($17.95), 9 inch round ($28.00), Half sheet ($60.50) and quarter sheet ($39.95).

PRICE
Varies by Size

Order Online!

Chocolate Cheesecake

This cheesecake is for serious chocolate lovers only! Best served with a red wine or cup of coffee. Slices available in store for $2.95.

SLICEWHOLE CAKE
$2.95$49.95

Chocolate Cream

(Our #1 seller) Regular pie crust, chocolate pudding filling, whipped topping and chocolate shavings, make this a real crowd pleaser of any age group.

10″ PRICE
$13.75

Order Online!

Coconut Cream

A single crust pie with a coconut flavored pudding, topped with either a meringue or a whipped topping – your preference must be indicated

10″ PRICE
$13.75

Order Online!

Dutch Apple

A single-crust pie with apple pie filling and a crunchy crumb topping of oatmeal, cinnamon, margarine and brown sugar.

10″ PRICE8″ PRICE
$13.75$7.95

Order Online!

French Coconut Pie

French coconut is only available in the month of April! We combine flaked coconut and oatmeal in a rich base, we pour it all in to a single crust pie and bake it to a golden perfection. Garnished with whipped topping.

10″ PRICE8″ PRICE
$14.75$8.25

Fresh Strawberry

(Seasonal May and June only) Strawberries in a jell like glaze with a regular pie crust, generously topped with whipped topping.

10″ PRICE
$16.95

Frosting

You can now buy a three pound pail of our famous buttercream frosting. Thaw and decorate your own cupcakes or birthday cakes. You can even add your own colors to make any holiday decorating easier and more enjoyable!

PRICE
$9.00 for 3 lbs.

Full Sheet Cake

Available in white, chocolate, marble or half white/half chocolate. Serves 60-96. Add an edible image for $7.50 to $10.00. Basic decorating included, advanced extra.

PRICE
$54.95

Half Sheet

Available in white, chocolate or marble. Serves 30-48. Add an edible image for $5.00. Basic decorating included, advanced extra

PRICE
$39.95

Kathy’s Plain Baked Cheesecake

Rich classic homemade cheese cake, made with cream cheese, sour cream and top shelf vanilla. Each cake is made by Kathy herself. We do have slices of this cheese cake available in our refrigerated case every day. Whole frozen cakes available in limited quantities.

SLICEWHOLE CAKE
$2.95$32.00

Order Online!

Key Lime Pie

A creamy filling made with juice direct from Key West makes this a tongue tantalizing treat anytime. A graham cracker crust and a garnishing of whipped topping finish it off…and no, it is not green.

10″ PRICE
$14.75

Order Online!

Mint Chocolate

Our PIE OF THE MONTH for the month of March; it is also available in December (by popular demand).

10″ PRICE
$14.75

P.B. Scotchies

Crispy rice, peanut butter, chocolate and butterscotch chips make for a tasty snack! $15.45 for a tray with approx. 24 servings or $2.25 for a snack cup.

EACH24 PIECES
$2.25$15.45

Order Online!

Peanut Butter Cream

A single-crust pie with a bottom layer of chocolate pudding, a top layer of peanut butter pudding and topped with whipped topping, peanuts and chocolate sauce.

10″ PRICE
$13.75

Order Online!

Pumpkin Bars

Moist Pumpkin Bars with our cream cheese frosting. You can purchase these as singles or a 1/4 sheet pan of them is cut in 16 servings

EACH16 PIECES
$1.05$10.95

Order Online!

Pumpkin Cheesecake

Fall classic, just like it sounds. Available with or without a cream cheese topping. Serves 16 – Limited Availability! Available by the slice in store $2.95.

SLICEWHOLE CAKE
$2.95$34.95

Pumpkin Cream

A tasty cream pie that is our PIE OF THE MONTH for September and November.

10″ PRICE
$13.75

Quarter Sheet Cake

Available in white, chocolate or marble. This size will serve 15-24. Add an edible image for $5.00. Basic decorating included, advanced extra.

PRICE
$27.00

Raisin Cream

A single-crust pie with a vanilla pudding base, raisins and nutmeg for seasoning. Topped with either a meringue or a whipped topping – your preference must be indicated.

10″ PRICE
$14.25

Order Online!

Toll House

A brownie-type pie in a regular pie crust – chocolate chips, and pecans make this a long-standing favorite among our regular customers

10″ PRICE8″ PRICE
$14.75$8.25

Order Online!

Toll House Bars

Toll House pie filling and our famous crust, just in a small bite size serving. (Net weight 2# 8 oz. 24 to 30 servings). Now available in a small platter size (12 oz.) for $3.95

SMALL TRAYLARGE TRAY
$3.95$15.45

Order Online!

Triple Chocolate Cupcakes

Just like the name says, this is a triple threat with chocolate chip cake, filled with dark chocolate frosting, topped with dark chocolate frosting. You need a whole gallon of milk with one of these!

PRICE
$2.49

Order Online!

Turnovers

Made with the same dough we use for our pies, so it’s just like getting a slice of pie! We make them every day in Apple, Cherry and Blueberry and a generous sprinkle of sugar.

EACH6 PACK
$1.95$11.70

Order Online!