Cookies

At Kathy’s Pies we make all of our cookies from recipes handed down from both of our grandmothers. We use real butter and the freshest ingredients and bake them fresh daily.

Holiday Frosted Cookies

Winter-themed or Christmas, we have you covered. Our cookies with edible images are $1.50 each or $15.95 a dozen.

EACH DOZEN
$1.60 $15.95

Lemon Bars

Sweet and tangy, our lemon bars are to die for, made with real lemon juice and a bottom crust with coconut in it.

EACH 32 PIECES
$1.35 $18.75

Order Online!

P.B. Scotchies

Crispy rice, peanut butter, chocolate and butterscotch chips make for a tasty snack! $16.75 for a large tray with approx. 24 servings or $5.75 for a Small Tray.

SMALL TRAY LARGE TRAY
$5.75 $16.75

Order Online!

Pumpkin Bars

Moist Pumpkin Bars with our cream cheese frosting. You can purchase these as singles or a 1/4 sheet pan of them is cut in 16 servings

EACH 16 PIECES
$1.35 $14.95

Order Online!

Toll House Bars

Toll House pie filling and our famous crust, just in a small bite size serving. (Net weight 2# 8 oz. 24 to 30 servings). Now available in a small platter size (12 oz.) for $4.95

SMALL TRAY LARGE TRAY
$5.75 $16.75

Order Online!