2 Crust Raisin
A double crust pie with a raisin filling with spices, not to be confused with a Raisin Cream.
| 10″ PRICE | 8″ PRICE |
|---|---|
| $14.25 | $8.25 |
Whole Pies
A variety of 10″ pies are available daily at the shop. 10″ pies will yield 8 servings each. Contact us for quantity discounts!
Apple
A great American standard, made with Granny Smith apples and a touch of cinnamon and nutmeg.
| 10″ PRICE | 8″ PRICE |
|---|---|
| $13.75 | $7.95 |
Apple No Sugar Added
A great American standard, made with Granny Smith apples and a touch of cinnamon and nutmeg.
| 10″ PRICE | |
|---|---|
| $14.25 |
Banana Cream
A single crust pie with real bananas in a banana flavored pudding, topped with either a meringue or a whipped topping – your preference must be indicated
| 10″ PRICE | – |
|---|---|
| $13.75 | – |
Banana Split Pie
This yummy creation is our pie of the month for August. (It is only available that month!) It has a banana…
| 10″ PRICE | – |
|---|---|
| $14.75 | – |
Bayou Goo
Cheesecake base with a layer of pecans, followed by a chocolate pudding layer finished with whipped topping…
| 10″ PRICE | – |
|---|---|
| $14.75 | – |
Butterscotch Cream
Real butterscotch fans only please! A creamy butterscotch filling, topped with either a meringue…
| 10″ PRICE | – |
|---|---|
| $13.75 | – |
Caramel Latte Pie
Coffee Lovers Only! Dark roast coffee is blended with rich milk, cream and vanilla pudding…
| 10″ PRICE | – |
|---|---|
| $14.75 | – |
Cheesecake
This is the no-bake version, with a graham cracker crust, creamy cheese cake filling…
| 10″ PRICE | – |
|---|---|
| $14.75 | – |
Cherry Crisp
A single-crust pie with cherry pie filling and a crumb topping of oatmeal, cinnamon, margarine and brown sugar.
| 10″ PRICE | 8″ PRICE |
|---|---|
| $13.75 | $7.95 |
Chocolate Cream
(Our #1 seller) Regular pie crust, chocolate pudding filling, whipped topping and chocolate shavings, make this a real crowd pleaser of any age group.
| 10″ PRICE | – |
|---|---|
| $13.75 | – |
Coconut Cream
A single crust pie with a coconut flavored pudding, topped with either a meringue or a whipped topping – your preference must be indicated
| 10″ PRICE | – |
|---|---|
| $13.75 | – |
Custard
An old fashion pie, in a regular crust – eggs, milk, sugar, salt , vanilla and nutmeg
| 10″ PRICE | 8″ PRICE |
|---|---|
| $12.25 | $6.45 |
Dutch Apple
A single-crust pie with apple pie filling and a crunchy crumb topping of oatmeal, cinnamon, margarine and brown sugar.
| 10″ PRICE | 8″ PRICE |
|---|---|
| $13.75 | $7.95 |
Dutch Caramel Apple
Dutch Apple Pie with an added layer of caramel sauce between pie filling and crumb topping.
| 10″ PRICE | 8″ PRICE |
|---|---|
| $14.75 | $8.25 |
French Coconut Pie
French coconut is only available in the month of April! We combine flaked coconut and oatmeal in a rich base, we pour it all in to a single crust pie and bake it to a golden perfection. Garnished with whipped topping.
| 10″ PRICE | 8″ PRICE |
|---|---|
| $14.75 | $8.25 |
Fresh Strawberry
(Seasonal May and June only) Strawberries in a jell like glaze with a regular pie crust, generously topped with whipped topping.
| 10″ PRICE | – |
|---|---|
| $16.95 | – |
German Chocolate
Pecan pie ingredients, chocolate, coconut, pecans and a whipped topping garnish
| 10″ PRICE | 8″ PRICE |
|---|---|
| $14.25 | $8.25 |
Key Lime Pie
A creamy filling made with juice direct from Key West makes this a tongue tantalizing treat anytime. A graham cracker crust and a garnishing of whipped topping finish it off…and no, it is not green.
| 10″ PRICE | – |
|---|---|
| $14.75 | – |
Lemon Supreme
A fluffy, light lemon filling, topped with whipped topping and accented with a tart lemon drizzle to finish it off.
| 10″ PRICE | – |
|---|---|
| $14.25 | – |
Mint Chocolate
Our PIE OF THE MONTH for the month of March; it is also available in December (by popular demand).
| 10″ PRICE | – |
|---|---|
| $14.75 | – |
Peach Crumb
A single-crust pie with peach pie filling and a crumb topping of oatmeal, cinnamon, margarine and brown sugar.
| 10″ PRICE | 8″ PRICE |
|---|---|
| $13.75 | $7.95 |
Peanut Butter Cream
A single-crust pie with a bottom layer of chocolate pudding, a top layer of peanut butter pudding and topped with whipped topping, peanuts and chocolate sauce.
| 10″ PRICE | |
|---|---|
| $13.75 |
Pecan
Another classic standard using the finest grade medium pecan pieces
| 10″ PRICE | 8″ PRICE |
|---|---|
| $14.25 | $8.25 |
Pumpkin
Traditional version – pumpkin, sugar, milk, eggs, pumpkin spice and vanilla
| 10″ PRICE | 8″ PRICE |
|---|---|
| $12.25 | $6.45 |
Pumpkin Cream
A tasty cream pie that is our PIE OF THE MONTH for September and November.
| 10″ PRICE | – |
|---|---|
| $13.75 | – |
Raisin Cream
A single-crust pie with a vanilla pudding base, raisins and nutmeg for seasoning. Topped with either a meringue or a whipped topping – your preference must be indicated.
| 10″ PRICE | – |
|---|---|
| $14.25 | – |
Raspberry Supreme
Tangy red raspberries and a cheesecake base combined to make a pleasing combination, in a regular pie crust with a garnish of whipped topping.
| 10″ PRICE | – |
|---|---|
| $14.75 | – |
Strawberry Rhubarb
Crimson rhubarb and strawberries make for a great combination.
| 10″ PRICE | 8″ PRICE |
|---|---|
| $13.75 | $7.95 |
Sweet Potato Pie
You asked for it! Limited availability, November and December.
| 10″ PRICE | 8″ PRICE |
|---|---|
| $12.25 | $6.45 |
Toll House
A brownie-type pie in a regular pie crust – chocolate chips, and pecans make this a long-standing favorite among our regular customers
| 10″ PRICE | 8″ PRICE |
|---|---|
| $14.25 | $8.25 |
Triple Berry
Cherries, blueberries, and raspberries make a great filling.
| 10″ PRICE | 8″ PRICE |
|---|---|
| $14.75 | $8.25 |